Muffin Paradox (part 2)

Ditzy Doo was getting confused more and more every time she trotted down another street.

Ditzy: (confused and a little worried) I swear I remember I used to live over here. But there’s no house and no Carrot Top.

She realize now this was a waste of time. So she decided to find the Doctor. She finally made it to the street where they were supposed to me. And to her surprised he wasn’t there either. She thought herself she should ask some pony. But sadly enough everypony went to bed. Until she noticed the light were still on at Sugar Cube Corner. Ditzy wondered if he was there and headed off to the source of the light.

…..
The Doctor slowly woke up, his vision a little fuzzy at first. Then suddenly readjusted and focused. The first thing he saw was a banner written in blood that said ‘life is a party’. The Doctor eyes grew from the site. He also notice Pony skeleton heads on a table underneath the banner wearing pony skins party hats.

Doctor: (his eyes widened even more, shaking his head slowly and speaking softly) No, no, no. This can’t be happening.

The Doctor also notices he was on a metal table and his limbs were bound. He couldn’t believe that this was happening. He couldn’t believe that these pony’s lives were taken away by some sick madman. He started to feel angry upon what he was seeing.

Doctor: (Barking in the room) alright! Who is responsible for this!

After he said that. He heard two voices. They sound like they were both giggling. And they stepped forward from the shadows and into the light. The Doctor was in shock.  He recognized the pink pony that he remembered her name was Pinky Pie or Ells Miranda so he thinks. But what he was most surprised at to see that made one of his heart thumping was his assistant.

Doctor: (Shock) D-Derpy! You’re behind this too?

Derpy nod her head. The Doctor felt hurt when, what he thought his companion responded to him. He almost felt heartbroken that his favorite pony was doing this especially to him.

Doctor: (gentle voice almost like he was going to cry) why would you do this? You kn-

Pinky: (interrupting and said cheerfully) because it’s fun!

Doctor: (angered, upset, and disturbed) fun? FUN! You think all of this is FUN!
Slaughtering innocents Ponies like this? I just feel ashamed; especially to you Derpy. I just can’t believe all this time you been doing this behind my back. And all the adventures that we’ve done together; and I was going to take you to that muf-

Derpy: (confused and cutting him off of his speech) what adventures? We never did anything together?... Well except the adventure were going to have now. (she smiled at the end)

The Doctor and Derpy stared at each other confused. That they seems that they didn’t knew each other. The Doctor was thinking for short brief minute until he realized something then smiled broadly at Derpy.

Doctor: (his usual cheery self) I’ve got it!

Pinky: (happily) he’s got it… Wait? Got what? ( she said now getting her confused)

Doctor: (smiled cheerfully) you’re not my Derpy.

Pinky and Derpy: what? (confused)

Doctor: (rambling) I just realized; you can be my Derpy. I mean, you are Derpy. But not the one I’ve been spending time with. Sure this must be a different time world where there’s a different one who does this sort of thing… I mean honestly you don’t know who I am of course. So… While this sort of happened to me once… Kind of? But that’s a different story anyway. Any who; point being you’re not my assistant that I’ve been traveling through space and time with. (Murmured to himself)I just hope my Derpy doesn’t find you here. I mean it probably will cause a paradox.

Pinky and Derpy looked at each other and confusion then go back at their victim. As he was still rumbling nonsense. Pinky shrugged her shoulders and pointed at the tools. Derpy saw the tools and nodded.

Derpy was going to get ready to torture the latest victim. She picked up a knife; the one that usually cuts off the cutiemark and began to work as Pinky watched her. Derpy walked over to the Doctor placed her  hoof onto his side and the knife gently touched the rim of his cutiemark.

Doctor: (now realizing Derpy was on his side.) hey, hey, HAY! What the bloody hell are you doing?

Derpy: (smile up at the Doctor began to giggle as she gently cut a little on his flesh) cutting off your cutiemark silly.

She began to cut the circle around his mark; blood spilling as the Doctor grits his teeth from the pain.

Doctor: (grits through his teeth) now you stop this immediately.
As soon as Derpy was almost  cutting off the flesh of his cutiemark. Suddenly Ditzy burst through the basement door clumsily.

Ditzy: woo! I think I sprained one of my wings on the way down.

Everypony gasp especially Derpy. She couldn’t believe she was seeing herself. Still the knife in Derpy’s hoof she was frozen from the sight of herself. The next second Ditzy slowly got up and saw Pinky Pie then smiled at her like it was nothing out of the ordinary going on. The next moment she turned her head then saw a very frozen in shock Derpy. Ditzy was in shock and wasn’t sure what she thought what she got herself into.